Henry V [1989]

Henry V [1989]

Welcome back to My Year of Shakespeare, the blog series where I watch and write about Shakespeare adaptations as a sort of penance for having the temerity to live another year.

This was the closest I got to enjoying a Branagh Shakespeare. I think Branagh just has too much love for the stage in a way that absolutely does not translate to its filmed depiction. I think of the three Branaghs we've seen for this (of six total), Henry V is the most approachable; that is not to be confused with describing the film as approachable. I think his adaptations have thus far very well embodied the popular perception that Shakespeare's plays are unapproachable, period-centric to a degree that they aren't truly adaptable, snooty, archaic, unfun; This is really quite a shame because I found some of the non-Branagh adaptations extremely engrossing, even when transposed from their original trappings — the subject matter isn't the issue.

Which is all to say, my perception has been that the Branagh adaptations are for the people who "know the story" and want "the faithful version". I guess that's not a thing that I can begrudge for existing, but the frequency with which these are recommended to first-time viewers is massively frustrating and does not build love for the genre amongst the uninitiated. It's a little like being a fan of a music group: you "know" that their "best album" isn't their "actual" best album; actually their second-worst, far less approachable album is their "true best" one.

Specifics

The four minute tracking shot that closes Act 4, I found interminable and did they do it handheld? It's so shaky; maybe I'm just swine who has pearls cast before him but who is this for? Were people especially moved by that? I mean, apparently they were, this was a Best Director nominee, but it did not appeal to me.

Emma Thompson is very clearly having fun with her role. Brian Blessed as Exeter was surprisingly understated; he is, however, very good at macroexpressions. Derek Jacobi is a delight in this, I think his role as Chorus should be in more movies.

Branagh as Henry, it was fine. No Hiddleston, but who is? Some of the scenes felt like maybe he was trying too hard; the courtship scene at the close with Thompson's Catherine, it felt like the contrapositive of Pepe Le Pew — characters in the same positions but linguistically twisted about. It's unclear to me how much of the Pepe Le Pew-ness was me coming in with an informed outside knowledge about the terminal of that relationship; reading that scene being insincere really clouds the whole story, so that's fun.

Per Donaldson, this film was in conversation with the Olivier version, from 1944. I did not see that version. I'd wager David Michod/Joel Edgerton's version is in conversation with this, given how both think through what a peace-desiring Henry would look like and only one of them stabs his underling who advocated for war square in the dome; this one has a sad king read a list of dead nobles then uses Michael Williams getting put in his place as a comedic beat. The lack of linguistic artifice in the Michod-Edgerton version likely assists in getting viewers on board; In comparison, until Agincourt, this was a tougher hang, in terms of accessibility or attention-absentee/second screen viewing — not unmanageable, but unconcerned with whether or not the audience member who would see themselves in Pistol or Falstaff was following. Then again, The King pictured a king who learned to be of his people, not above them, somehow a proletariat king; a goofy contradiction. Nothing so nonsensical here. Just social betters sending their unwashed masses to die and feeling really bad about it, even when that means sweet Jack Falstaff, valiant Jack Falstaff.

I had a pretty good time with this. Not a great one, but a fine one. If, for whatever reason, the Hollow Crown's version is out of reach for you, or the Branagh Hamlet really, really hit for you, you could certainly do worse than this one.

Next week, we have our penultimate Henriad episode of "The Black Adder" / Blackadder series one, from 1983. Then our schedule is:

  • Nov 29: The Goodbye Girl (1977) & Looking for Richard (1996)
  • Dec 6: The Tempest (1998)
  • Dec 12: Yellow Sky (1948) & Forbidden Planet (1956)
  • Dec 19: Shakespeare's Shitstorm (2020) & Prospero's Books (1991)
  • Dec 26: The Tempest (2010, dir Julie Taymore)

And then we're done. Thank you for playing along at home with My Year of Shakespeare.